Hearts vs Livingston — result, stats and line-ups

Full Time

2023/2024

Hearts

13 APR

4:2

Livingston

Goals

GOAL

Goal10'

Sean Kelly · Left foot shot 0-1

GOAL

AST

Goal22'

Sean Kelly (assist: Tete Yengi) · Right foot shot 0-2

GOAL

AST

Goal29'

Jorge Grant (assist: Lawrence Shankland) · Right foot shot 1-2

GOAL

AST

Goal32'

Yutaro Oda (assist: Lawrence Shankland) · Left foot shot 2-2

GOAL

AST

Goal40'

Cammy Devlin (assist: Alex Cochrane) · Right foot shot 3-2

GOAL

Penalty45'

Lawrence Shankland · Right foot shot 4-2

Man of the match

Lawrence ShanklandHearts9.5

Expected goals (xG)

HeartsxGLivingston

3.771.21

AI forecast

Tippio

The AI forecast opens in the Tippio app

An AI subscription opens everything. You can also earn it by tipping: tip at least 70% of a league's matches in a week and next week it's yours for free. A single outcome opens by watching an ad. Sign in and it shows here too, if you have access.

Get the app

TV stations

International

Bet365

Venue

Tynecastle ParkEdinburgh · 19,852 seats

Larger map ›

Conditions

Weatherlight rain
RefereeColin Steven
1st AssistantJonathan Bell
2nd AssistantGraham McNeillie
4th OfficialDuncan Williams

Pressure index

HeartsLivingston

1′45′90′

Which side was pressing, minute by minute. The markers are the events: tap one to read the minute and the player — and, with ball positions loaded, the replay jumps there.

Match flow

GOAL

Goal10'

Sean Kelly · Left foot shot 0-1

GOAL

AST

Goal22'

Sean Kelly (assist: Tete Yengi) · Right foot shot 0-2

GOAL

AST

Goal29'

Jorge Grant (assist: Lawrence Shankland) · Right foot shot 1-2

PLAYER

Yellow card31'

Tete Yengi · Foul

GOAL

AST

Goal32'

Yutaro Oda (assist: Lawrence Shankland) · Left foot shot 2-2

PLAYER

Yellow card32'

Tete Yengi · Substitution because of injury

GOAL

AST

Goal40'

Cammy Devlin (assist: Alex Cochrane) · Right foot shot 3-2

PLAYER

Yellow card45'

Alex Cochrane · Foul

GOAL

Penalty45'

Lawrence Shankland · Right foot shot 4-2

OUT

Substitution57'

In: Bruce Anderson · Out: Tete Yengi · Tactical sub

OUT

Substitution60'

In: Kenneth Vargas · Out: Alex Cochrane · Tactical sub

OUT

Substitution60'

In: Stephen Kingsley · Out: Barrie McKay · Tactical sub

OUT

Substitution66'

In: Alan Forrest · Out: Cammy Devlin · Tactical sub

OUT

Substitution67'

In: S. Fraser · Out: Yutaro Oda · Tactical sub

OUT

Substitution72'

In: Mo Sangare · Out: J. Holt · Tactical sub

OUT

Substitution74'

In: Kyosuke Tagawa · Out: Jorge Grant · Tactical sub

OUT

Substitution78'

In: David Carson · Out: Jamie Brandon · Tactical sub

Ball positions

The ball's path over the whole match or one half: press play to run through it, drag the slider to jump anywhere. Loaded on request to keep the page light.

Commentary

108

And that's it. The match concludes - Heart of Midlothian triumphs with 4, Livingston settles for 2.
90+5′The final whistle has blown for the second half - Heart of Midlothian triumphs with 4 goals against Livingston's 2.
90+2′Lawrence Shankland commits a foul - Heart of Midlothian.
90+2′Daniel Mackay of Livingston has successfully earned a defensive free kick.
90+1′Nathaniel Atkinson of Heart of Midlothian has earned a defensive free kick.
90+1′Fouled by Daniel Mackay - Livingston
90′Attempt thwarted. Alan Forrest of Heart of Midlothian's right-footed shot from the middle of the penalty area is intercepted. The assist came from Lawrence Shankland.Penalty
89′Fouled by Scott Pittman - Livingston
89′Alan Forrest - Heart of Midlothian - won a free kick in defence.
87′Frankie Kent commits a foul - Heart of Midlothian.
87′Bruce Anderson of Livingston has earned an offensive free kick.
86′Offside - Heart of Midlothian. Kyosuke Tagawa is in offside.
83′Opportunity squandered. Daniel Mackay of Livingston fires a left-footed shot from beyond the box that veers left of the goal. The assist was provided by Michael Devlin.
82′Opportunity squandered. Ayo Obileye of Livingston fails to convert a header from within the six-yard box on the left side, sending it wide of the left post. The setup came from Sean Kelly, who delivered a cross following a corner kick.
81′Corner kick awarded to Livingston, resulting from a deflection off Lawrence Shankland.
81′Attempt thwarted. Sean Kelly of Livingston's left-footed shot from beyond the box is intercepted.
80′Scott Pittman of Livingston has earned an attacking free kick.
80′Stephen Kingsley from Heart of Midlothian commits a foul.
78′Player swap for Livingston. Jamie Brandon is replaced by David Carson.
75′Attempt thwarted. Alan Forrest of Heart of Midlothian's right-footed shot from the left side of the penalty area is intercepted. The assist was provided by Lawrence Shankland.Penalty
74′Player change - Heart of Midlothian. Jorge Grant is being replaced by Kyosuke Tagawa.
72′Opportunity squandered. Michael Devlin of Livingston takes a right-footed shot from beyond the box but it veers left, missing the goal. The assist was provided by Sean Kelly.
72′Player swap for Livingston. Jason Holt is being replaced by Mohammed Sangare.
67′Opportunity squandered. Lawrence Shankland of Heart of Midlothian takes a right-footed shot from beyond the box, but it sails high and wide to the right. The assist was by Jorge Grant.
67′Player change - Heart of Midlothian. Yutaro Oda is replaced by Scott Fraser.
66′Player switch - Heart of Midlothian. Cameron Devlin makes way for Alan Forrest.
64′Opportunity squandered. Cameron Devlin of Heart of Midlothian takes a right-footed shot from the middle of the penalty area, it's a near miss but it goes wide to the left. The cross came in from Jorge Grant.Penalty
61′Attempt thwarted. Lawrence Shankland of Heart of Midlothian's left-footed strike from beyond the box is obstructed. The assist was provided by Yutaro Oda.
61′New attacking attempt. Lawrence Shankland - Heart of Midlothian - shot with right foot from the right side of the box is saved in the top centre of the goal.
61′Shot blocked. Jorge Grant - Heart of Midlothian - shot with right foot from the left side of the box is blocked.
60′Corner kick awarded to Heart of Midlothian, forced by Michael Nottingham's defensive play.
60′Player change - Heart of Midlothian. Alex Cochrane is being replaced by Stephen Kingsley.
59′Player swap - Heart of Midlothian. Kenneth Vargas is coming on for Barrie McKay.
59′Jason Holt of Livingston has secured a defensive free kick.
59′Cameron Devlin from Heart of Midlothian commits a foul.
58′Tete Yengi of Livingston has just received his second yellow card in the match.
57′Player switch - Livingston. Bruce Anderson is coming in for Tete Yengi.
52′Opportunity missed. Michael Nottingham of Livingston narrowly misses the goal with a header from just a few metres away. Stephen Kelly provided the assist with a cross following a corner kick.
52′Livingston has been awarded a corner kick, due to Beni Baningime's defensive action.
51′Corner kick awarded to Livingston, forced by Nathaniel Atkinson's defensive play.
49′Offside - Called against Livingston. Ayo Obileye has been flagged for offside.
49′Jason Holt of Livingston has secured a free kick on the left flank.
49′Fouled by Yutaro Oda - Heart of Midlothian
46′Nathaniel Atkinson from Heart of Midlothian has secured a defensive free kick.
46′Daniel Mackay from Livingston commits a foul.
45′The second half kicks off with Heart of Midlothian leading 4-2 against Livingston.
45+7′The first half has concluded with Heart of Midlothian leading 4-2 against Livingston.
45+6′Goal! Heart of Midlothian 4, Livingston 2. Lawrence Shankland - Heart of Midlothian - converts the penalty with a shot with right foot to the top left corner.
45+5′Shamal George of Livingston has given away a penalty following a violation in the penalty box.Penalty
45+5′Penalty awarded to Heart of Midlothian. Yutaro Oda is fouled inside the penalty box.Penalty
45+4′Pause finished. They are prepared to proceed.
45+3′Match pause - Alex Cochrane of Heart of Midlothian is injured.
45+1′Alex Cochrane of Heart of Midlothian has been handed a yellow card due to a foul.
45+1′Scott Pittman of Livingston has successfully earned a defensive free kick.
45+1′Alex Cochrane of Heart of Midlothian commits a foul.
45+1′Yutaro Oda of Heart of Midlothian has successfully secured a defensive free kick.
44′Jorge Grant of Heart of Midlothian has successfully earned a defensive free kick.
44′Jamie Brandon from Livingston commits a foul.
43′Stephen Kelly from Livingston commits a foul.
43′Cameron Devlin of Heart of Midlothian has earned an offensive free kick.
40′Goal! Heart of Midlothian 3, Livingston 2. Cameron Devlin - Heart of Midlothian - shot with right foot inside of six yard box - left side to the left corner. Assist - Alex Cochrane with a cross.
37′Offside call - Livingston. Tete Yengi has been flagged for offside.
36′Tete Yengi of Livingston has committed a foul.
36′Craig Gordon of Heart of Midlothian has earned a defensive free kick.
35′Corner kick awarded to Livingston, forced by Alex Cochrane.
33′Yutaro Oda - Heart of Midlothian - won a free kick in attack.
33′Fouled by Jamie Brandon - Livingston
32′Score! Heart of Midlothian ties it up 2-2 against Livingston. Yutaro Oda of Heart of Midlothian fires a left-footed shot from a short distance into the left corner. The assist came from Lawrence Shankland.
31′Tete Yengi of Livingston has been handed a yellow card due to a foul.
31′Tete Yengi of Livingston commits a foul.
31′Cameron Devlin from Heart of Midlothian has successfully earned a defensive free kick.
29′Goal! Heart of Midlothian 1, Livingston 2. Jorge Grant - Heart of Midlothian - shot with right foot from few metres to the centre of the goal. Assist - Lawrence Shankland.
27′Lawrence Shankland of Heart of Midlothian has successfully earned a free kick on the right flank.
27′Ayo Obileye of Livingston commits a foul.
26′Pause concluded. They are prepared to resume.
25′Match pause - Lawrence Shankland of Heart of Midlothian is injured.
25′Jason Holt of Livingston has earned a defensive free kick.
25′Nathaniel Atkinson of Heart of Midlothian is penalized for committing a foul.
24′Yutaro Oda from Heart of Midlothian has earned a defensive free kick.
24′Sean Kelly of Livingston commits a foul.
23′Stephen Kelly from Livingston commits a foul.
23′Beni Baningime - Heart of Midlothian - won a free kick in attack.
22′Score! Heart of Midlothian 0, Livingston 2. Stephen Kelly of Livingston fires a right-footed shot from beyond the box into the left corner. The assist came from Tete Yengi.
21′Jorge Grant of Heart of Midlothian has earned an attacking free kick.
21′Scott Pittman of Livingston commits a foul.
20′Scott Pittman from Livingston commits a foul.
20′Alex Cochrane of Heart of Midlothian has successfully earned a defensive free kick.
18′Pause ended. They are prepared to proceed.
17′Match pause - Ayo Obileye of Livingston is injured.
15′Corner kick awarded to Heart of Midlothian, forced by Michael Devlin's defensive play.
13′Michael Nottingham of Livingston has successfully secured a defensive free kick.
13′Frankie Kent commits a foul - Heart of Midlothian.
13′Corner kick awarded to Heart of Midlothian, courtesy of a deflection off Michael Devlin.
10′Score! Heart of Midlothian trails 0 to 1 against Livingston. Stephen Kelly of Livingston fires a left-footed shot from beyond the box, landing it dead centre of the net.
9′New attacking attempt. Tete Yengi - Livingston - shot with right foot from the centre of the box is saved by goalkeeper in the centre of the goal.
7′Corner kick awarded to Heart of Midlothian, forced by Sean Kelly's defense.
7′Attempt thwarted. Jorge Grant of Heart of Midlothian's right-footed shot from beyond the box is obstructed.
7′Attempt thwarted. Kye Rowles of Heart of Midlothian's left-footed strike from beyond the box is intercepted.
6′Corner kick awarded to Heart of Midlothian, forced by Michael Devlin's defensive play.
4′Corner - Livingston. Conceded by Beni Baningime.
4′Michael Devlin of Livingston commits a foul.
4′Alex Cochrane of Heart of Midlothian has earned a defensive free kick.
3′Jason Holt of Livingston has earned an offensive free kick.
3′Cameron Devlin from Heart of Midlothian commits a foul.
2′Offside called against Livingston. Scott Pittman has been flagged for being offside.
2′Jorge Grant - Heart of Midlothian - won a free kick in defence.
2′Jamie Brandon from Livingston commits a foul.
The initial half commences..

Match statistics

HEALIV

Possession and passing

62%Possession38%

77%Pass accuracy67%

508Passes314

394Successful Passes212

8Key Passes5

5Substitutions3

1 more

25Throw-ins15

Attack

4Goals2

13Shots Total8

5Shots On Target3

5Corners5

49Dangerous Attacks34

2Accurate Crosses3

12 more

113Attacks89

22Dribble Attempts16

62Duels Won55

1Offsides3

1Penalties0

6Shots Blocked1

9Shots inside the box4

2Shots Off Target4

4Shots outside the box4

75%Successful dribbles25%

10Successful Dribbles4

15Total Crosses10

Defence and discipline

1Saves1

19Tackles17

2Interceptions11

9Fouls17

1Yellow cards2

0Red cards0

Other

1Hit Woodwork0

13Successful Headers26

12Successful Interceptions15

25Headers54

1Challenges8

3Assists1

1 more

1Counter Attacks0

The halves are each period's own numbers — not a split of the full-time figures.

The referee

C. StevenPer-match averages this season · 9 matches · career: 58

	Avg	Home	Away	Career
Yellow cards	4.22	1.78	2.44	4.16
Red cards	0.11	0.00	0.11	0.17
Second yellows	0.11	0.00	0.11	0.12
Penalties	0.44	0.33	0.11	0.40

Home / away: what the home and the away side received on average. Career: the average over every match officiated.

Expected goals (xG)

HeartsxGLivingston

3.771.21

Expected Goals on Target (xGoT)

3.080.61

Expected Goals Non Penalty Goals (npxG)

2.981.21

Expected Goals Open Play (xGOP)

2.910.33

Expected Goals Set Play (xGSP)

0.860.89

Expected Goals Corners (xGC)

0.070.84

Expected Goals Free Kicks (xGFK)

0.000.04

Expected Points (xPTS)

2.580.32

Starting XI

LivingstonFormation: 4-1-4-1 · €416K3/11

David Martindale

HeartsFormation: 4-2-3-1 · €14M6/11

Steven Naismith

The ↓ and minute under a player mean they were substituted off then.

Transfer fees

Hearts€14Mstarting XI · 6/11€17Mwith bench · 7/20

Livingston€416Kstarting XI · 3/11€416Kwith bench · 3/16

Hearts's starting XI cost €14M more.

The amount under a player is their last known transfer fee and its year (provider data) — not a market value.

Hearts — bench

Stephen KingsleyDefender · €3.3M (2017)6.4 17

Alan ForrestAttacker6.7 22

Aidan DenholmMidfielder25

Macaulay TaitMidfielder28

Zander ClarkGoalkeeper29

S. FraserMidfielder7.0 30

Kyosuke TagawaAttacker6.4 77

Kenneth VargasAttacker7.0 81

Dexter LembikisaDefender

Livingston — bench

David CarsonMidfielder6.4 9

Bruce AndersonAttacker6.6 16

Steven BradleyAttacker20

Mo SangareMidfielder7.0 32

Jack HamiltonGoalkeeper

Player statistics

Hearts starters then subs, by rating

Lawrence Shankland#9 · Attacker · 90′9.5

In this match

Attack

Goals: 1
Assists: 2
Shots: 4
Shots on target: 2
Big chances created: 2
Expected goals (xG): 0.87
xGoT: 0.85
Hit woodwork: 1
Penalties scored: 1

Passing

Passes (accurate/total): 33/44
Pass accuracy: 75%
Key passes: 4
Crosses (accurate/total): 0/3
Long balls (won/total): 3/5

Possession & duels

Touches: 0
Duels (won/total): 3/9
Aerials won: 1
Dribbles (won/attempted): 1/4

Defence

Tackles: 0
Blocked shots: 1

Discipline

Fouls: 1
Fouls drawn: 1

Player	Reason	Back
Craig Halkett🩹 injury · Knee Problems	injury · Knee Problems	1 Jun 2024
Peter Haring🩹 injury · Knee Surgery	injury · Knee Surgery	29 Apr 2024

Outcome	bet365	Unibet
Hearts	1.4568.97%	1.3375.19%
Draw	4.7521.05%	5.0020%
Livingston	6.0016.67%	8.0012.5%

Outcome	bet365	Unibet
Hearts or Draw	1.1288.89%	1.0793.46%
Hearts or Livingston	1.1884.67%	1.1785.47%
Draw or Livingston	2.6238.1%	3.1531.75%

Outcome	bet365	Unibet
2+ goals	–	1.2281.97%
0–1 goals	–	4.0025%
3+ goals	1.8055.56%	1.7557.14%
0–2 goals	2.0050%	2.1047.62%
4+ goals	–	2.8535.09%
0–3 goals	–	1.3872.46%

Outcome	bet365	Unibet
Hearts	1.9551.23%	1.7955.87%
Draw	2.4041.67%	2.5539.22%
Livingston	6.5015.38%	6.7514.81%

Outcome	bet365
HEA → HEA	2.2544.44%
HEA → X	15.006.67%
HEA → LIV	41.002.44%
X → HEA	4.0025%
X → X	6.5015.38%
X → LIV	13.007.69%
LIV → HEA	21.004.76%
LIV → X	17.005.88%
LIV → LIV	11.009.09%

Outcome	bet365
12 - 14	3.5028.57%
6 - 8	4.0025%
9 - 11	2.6238.1%
Under 6	15.006.67%
Over 14	6.0016.67%

#	Team	P	Pts
1	Celtic	7	18
2	Rangers	7	16
3	Hearts	7	13
4	Dundee	7	10
5	St. Mirren	7	10
6	St. Johnstone	7	8
7	Aberdeen	7	8
8	Dundee United	7	8
9	Motherwell	7	8
10	Hibernian	7	7
11	Falkirk	7	6
12	Kilmarnock	7	5

Outcome	bet365	Unibet
Yes	1.9551.28%	2.0848.08%
No	1.8055.56%	1.7058.82%